NOT "ani extra," I tried this with it side by side. Dr. Rumney's green, to my nose, has a sharper aniseed, higher nicotine, and longer lasting menthol. I did not smell the florals as much as I thought, considering the description, and I really enjoy this one. I think Wilson's ani extra is a lighter version of this, more suited to all day use, while green could still fit that bill, it is more of a heavier version. If you like either, try them both! I enjoy licorice, anise and aniseed snuffs a lot. This is one of the best ones I have tried.