I liked this one, and actually tried it because of how one online reviewer on another website said it was "so horrid" that I had to see for myself. Well, I did not find it horrid at all. My only complaint with it, is that it is a touch dry causing a bit of a burn, but the top note was quite enjoyable. I enjoy real fruit cake, and I would not say these have the zame scent, as this snuff is less sweet, more nutty, and less cloying. Definitely one to try if you like cake!