I am not generally a fan of unmedicated florals Because they tend to be either too perfumy and old lady-ish, or too soapy. This is pretty good though! The Rose scent is undeniably strong, but stops short of over powering the tobacco base. I have trouble deciding whether I like better this or the WS Rows of Sharrow. I lean toward this one , though. Personally, I don’t see myself sniffng it Straight much. I did, however, mix it into some of my darker, earthier snuffs to give them a bit of “lift” and the effect was incredible. If you are like me and don’t go much for florals, this is nevertheless a good one to keep on hand for mixing (seriously- try putting a tiny sprinkling onto a mound of Bernard Aecht- you will be surprised at the result!). If you like florals, then I can see this being a five star for you.